George’s Buttermilk Pie
Updated on June 12, 2024 by Rodney • This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. • 1 Comment • Jump to Recipe
George’s Buttermilk Pie recipe has been a tradition in our family for decades. Super easy to make with one of the most unique flavors!
My wife’s Grandpa George used to make this Buttermilk Pie all the time during the Holidays. I had never heard of this pie before and I love to make old family recipes so I just had to try George’s Buttermilk Pie.
My first reaction was what does it taste like? Looking at the recipe I figured it would be a custard kind of pie like my Cinnamon Sugar Cream Pie. Well I was close.
The filling is just like a custard, not too stiff and not too runny. As far as the flavor goes, it has a bit of a sour taste to it thanks to the buttermilk but not terribly sweet with just a hint of nutmeg.
For the pie crust, I used the deep dish variety. When I poured the buttermilk mixture into the prepared pie shell it filled it to the top. You need to be mindful of that when shopping for a pie crust.
Buttermilk Substitution
If you don’t have Buttermilk on hand, you can use this trick as a substitute: Add one tablespoon of lemon juice to a measuring cup. Add milk and fill to the 1 cup measurement line. Stir the mixture together and let sit for 5 minutes.
Another option is to use a cultured buttermilk blend. All you need to do is add water. I was very skeptical at first but in a pinch it works great!
If you love making homemade pies, make sure you check out my delicious selection of Pies & Tarts Recipes. My Mom’s Raisin Pie recipe is one of the most popular pie recipes on our site!
You can either eat it plain as I do or with a dollop of whipped cream or even with a berry topping like blueberries or strawberries. Apparently making this buttermilk pie with pecans is another popular version of this old school recipe.
Gather your Ingredients
You will need the following ingredients to make George’s Buttermilk Pie recipe (see recipe card for quantities): Unsalted Butter, White Sugar, Eggs, All Purpose Flour, Ground Nutmeg, Buttermilk, Vanilla Extract and a Pie Crust.
How to Make George’s Buttermilk Pie
- Preheat oven to 325°F.
- Prepare the pie shell according to the directions on the package. Usually baking it for 8 – 10 minutes.
- In a mixing bowl, cream the butter. Gradually add the sugar. Add eggs one at a time mixing well between each.
- Stir in the All Purpose Flour and Nutmeg and beat until blended. Add Buttermilk and vanilla and beat well.
- Pour the buttermilk mixture into the prepared pie crust.
- Bake for 55 minutes or until set. The center should still be a little jiggly. Let cool on a wire rack.
Printable Recipe Card
George’s Buttermilk Pie
Equipment
Ingredients
- ⅓ Cup Unsalted Butter, Softened
- 1 ½ Cup White Sugar
- 3 Eggs
- 3 Tbsp All Purpose Flour
- ¼ Tsp Ground Nutmeg
- 1 Cup Buttermilk
- 1 Tsp Vanilla Extract
- 9 inch Refrigerated Pie Crust, unbaked
Instructions
- Preheat oven to 325F.
- Prepare the pie shell according to the directions on the package. Usually baking it for 8 – 10 minutes.
- In a mixing bowl, cream the butter. Gradually add the sugar. Add eggs one at a time mixing well between each.
- Add Flour and Nutmeg and beat until blended. Add Buttermilk and vanilla and beat well.
- Pour buttermilk mixture into prepared pie crust.
- Bake for 55 minutes or until set. The center should still be a little jiggly. Let cool on wire rack.
Notes
Nutrition
Nutritional information provided for this recipe is based on 1 serving. This information is an estimate and may vary based on several factors. If nutritional information is important to you and your diet, please verify this recipe with a Registered Dietitian.
This buttermilk pie was really tasty. Just like a custard pie. The nutmeg gives this pie a sweet but not too sweet taste.